Book 1 was ok; it needed more exclamation in spots and moved a bit to quickly. BUT book 2 was fantastic very good story Windrow fixed my issues with book 1 and put out a very good story great characters book 3 was just as good I don't understand the bad reviews this book was well written lots of character growth along with all the action, drama, romance and yes humor (Nathan) so I don't get the bad reviews. Don't go off them this was a really good story but you do need to read/listen to all three. So do yourself a favor: get the Audible books; narration was very good. Hope there will be more of Alexis Black and company; her story isn't done yet. Highly recommend.